News Line

    Go to Home Back
Email this to a friend
Printable version
Thursday, June 23, 2011 - 06.30 GMT
SL envoys in US reveal inconsistencies in Channel 4 video

 

Sri Lanka’s Permanent Representative to the UN Dr. Palitha Kohona and Deputy Permanent Representative Major General Shavendra Silva yesterday revealed about the inconsistencies and the biased narration of the documentary aired by Channel 4 recently.

The Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the International Crisis Group who claimed that the documentary reinforces the findings of the Darusman Report organised a screening of the Channel 4 documentary at the UN Church Centre yesterday.

The two Sri Lankan diplomats told the gathering the Channel 4 video fiasco is a well-planned ploy to tarnish a country which succeeded in eradicating a deadly terrorist organization which held thousands of innocent civilians hostage.

During the opening statements, Amnesty International stated that the documentary presented “very strong evidence of war crimes” and that there was a “consistent pattern of human rights violations within the Sri Lankan forces.” Human Rights Watch also alleges that this documentary proves that war crimes were committed and that “the Sri Lanka government cannot be relied upon for justice”. The purpose of this screening, they claimed was to urge the international community to conduct independent investigations.

All of the above accusations as well as the credibility of the Channel 4 documentary was scrutinized by Sri Lanka’s Permanent Representative to the UN, Dr. Palitha Kohona and Deputy Permanent Representative, Ambassador Major General Shavendra Silva, who were given the opportunity to respond to the documentary.

The inconsistencies as well as the biased narration of the documentary were brought to the audience’s attention by the Ambassador Shavendra Silva. Proclamations which were known to be blatant lies as well as the true identities of the individuals in which the movie revolves around were pointed out by Ambassador Silva. Video evidence to support these explanations was not permitted to be displayed by Amnesty International.

Ambassador Major General Shavendra Silva informed the audience, that one visual shown in the documentary, displaying an aerial bombing to a specific target in the jungle area, but the Channel 4 uses that particular clip fighter jets purposly bombing a civilian gathering but it was two separate locations but the narrator tried to portray that the casualties occurred owing to the bombing, which the audience accepted.

General Silva informed the audience during this clip, the filmmaker uses two eyewitnesses namely Vany Kumar and Dr. Shanmugaraj. Vany Kumar she had three different alias as in different locations. Namely, Damilvany Kumar, Vany Kumar, Damilvany Gananakumar. The Channel 4 programme says she had been in Sri Lanka only for six months but Ambassador Silva highlighted her stay in Sri Lanka, what her family in the UK has informed through the guardian.co.uk in an interview and proved to the audience that she was infact an LTTE activist and her credibility in the documentary.

Ambassador General Silva also revealed several statements made by Dr. Shanmugaraja who admits to have given false information to the International Media due to LTTE pressure.

Ambassador Silva pointed out the false translation depicted during the clip where civilians are in a trench was also brought to light. The civilians in the trench are shown shouting at the cameraman for recording this and the false translation provided for the Tamil being spoken, is clear evidence that this was infact staged.

In response the filmmaker Cullum McRae informed that Ambassador Silva would have appeared in front of the LLRC which he had not done. At this point Ambassador Silva, informed the audience again how untrue the facts and the allegations made by the filmmaker without knowing the correct information where Major General Silva has appeared twice in front of the LLRC to present testimonies.
 

                   

 
   
   
     
   
   

top

   

Contact Information:: Send mail to priu@presidentsoffice.lk with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: June 23, 2011.

Copyright © 2008 Policy Research & Information Unit of the Presidential Secretariat of Sri Lanka. All Rights Reserved.